Character is that which reveals moral purpose, exposing the class of things a man chooses or avoids.– Aristotle
In other words, what we do shows our true Character. For good or ill, how we behave is truly the mark of who we are.
We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit.-Aristotle
Excellence is measured in many ways. Wins, a great batting average, achieving a Gold standard in the Journey to Excellence program, becoming an Eagle Scout, or raising your children to be great adults. What is comes down to are the habits that your form to achieve excellence. How can Scouting help one develop these habits? Simple, but providing programs that move toward the aims of Scouting. Keeping the Scout Oath and Law at the forefront of everything that we do in Scouting. Ensuring that character, citizenship, and fitness are never missing when we reflect on the game we play.
The values expressed in the Oath and Law become those habits that drive us to excellence. We measure that daily when we lay in bed at night and reflect on the day. Did we help other people? Did we make a difference in someone’s life? Were we kind and courteous? Were we friendly and obedient? Did we do all we can to be someone that can be trusted and counted on? Were we thrifty with our resources, our money, and our environment? Do we ask ourselves these questions so that tomorrow we can be a better person that wants to be excellent? That is how we shape our character and maintain it.
As Scouters, did we do something today to enrich the lives of our Scouts and their families? Are we the role model to them? What does that mean to you and what are you doing about it?
We are what we repeatedly do. Can you honestly say you do your best? I know it’s a struggle at times, but we need to try and try hard. Everything that we do is seen by our Scouts. They look to us to be models of character. To them maybe the concept of character is still a bit foggy. What they see in you will make a difference in how they develop those habits.
The greatest virtues are those which are most useful to other persons. – Aristotle.
The most worth-while thing is to try to put happiness into the lives of others.– Baden Powell
Have a Great Scouting Day!
Character is that which reveals moral purpose, exposing the class of things a man chooses or avoids.– Aristotle
If you play a game that has a desired outcome or purpose it is important that you first know what that purpose is and then have some way of knowing if you achieved the results you were looking for.
By and large that is the reason we have an Eagle Scout Board of Review. We can assess and determine though the interview with the Scout whether or not the program is delivering the promise of Scouting and achieving its goals of helping make young people of character, good citizens, that are physically fit. Along with all of that, do they make ethical choices and does it look like they will do the same in the future.
Reflection is an important part of every thing that we do in Scouting. It allows us to take a look back and see if we achieved the outcomes we want in playing our game.
Reflection comes in many forms, we can do it as a group or take time in silent reflection. But no activity is complete until the reflection is done.
This last weekend our Troop went camping. First winter camp out of the year and we went caving on Saturday exploring the largest Lava tube cave in the US. It is adventurous and challenging and our Scouts love to test themselves. As with most outings or activities a theme develops throughout the weekend. This weekend the theme quickly became “Rising to the Challenge”. Overcoming hardship, attitudes, and things that make you uncomfortable were some of the behaviors that we noticed in our Scouts as they went through the weekend.
For some of the Scouts it was the first time they would camp in sub freezing temperatures. For some it was their first time in a cave. For others it was a leadership challenge as they learned that as a leader there were Scouts that depended on them to just get through the weekend. Cold weather, challenging experiences, and doing something new and difficult.
These young men learned and practiced great leadership. I was pleased to watch as members of the Patrol Leaders Council made their way through camp checking on the younger Scouts. Instructing them on how to get through the night. Reassuring younger Scouts that they will be ok and that if they do what they are taught, they will be warmer in the morning and will be able to have a better experience in winter camping.
I walked through camp Saturday night around 10:30 and found gear properly stored, tents pitched with all the tie outs in place and the sounds of tired happy Scouts sitting in their tents, the gentle glow of a headlamp lighting the green nylon of a tent fly.
Sunday morning leadership was once again challenged as cold fingers attempted to pack even colder nylon tents and sleeping bags. Our departure time was supposed to be 9:00 AM. We missed it by 20 minutes, but the reason was acceptable to me. The Troop was in Patrol lines taking a few minutes to share a few things they learned over the weekend. Patrol leaders talking with their patrols about the challenges they faced over the weekend and how they all rose to the challenge. Before we loaded up I shared with them my pride in them and how they are great young men. I shared with them the fact that they needed to reflect on the weekend and see just how much they learned about skills, their attitude, and how they grew because of the experience. The final question that I asked them to reflect on was this, Is there any place you would rather be?
When we got back to the hall and parents started arriving to pick up their Scouts, many of the Scouts came to me and shared the answer to that last question. Each and every one of them say “NO WHERE ELSE”.
So reflecting back on this weekend I would say Promise Delivered and Program solid.
It is important to reflect. You may not always get the answer you want, that is your opportunity to learn and grow doing better next time. If things are going well… keep it that way! Don’t let it slip.
Make sure that reflection time is a part of your program. Have the Scouts take time to reflect and have serious reflection on how they are doing in the Scouting program. It is a game with a purpose, without reflection, you will not know if that purpose is being met.
Have a Great Scouting Day!
A Scout Troop is a family.. and it’s either living or dying. It’s either growing or shrinking, viable or withering on the vine. There are many reasons for this, but the point of the matter is that if we are not watching for it we will let units fail. It isn’t always easy to pinpoint one thing or another, but the more you focus the clearer the issues become and the faster a unit can recover when it finds itself dying.
I find that a close examination of the how the unit is using the methods is a great start. Oh and by the way, this is important for units that are living and living well too. You may just find that you are slipping in an area that down the road can lead to a cancer that can not be cured in the unit.
Is the unit using all eight of the methods or just picking and choosing which ones are important to them? I liken that practice to picking and choosing which of the values in the Scout Law are less important and need not apply.
A strong program relies on the methods to achieve the goals of Scouting. Too many units favor advancement over other methods. I have seen those units race their Scouts to Eagle and then die.. they lost the older Scouts and leadership. The families disengage once their son “Eagles Out” [a term that does not have any place in Scouting]. There is no longer a dog in the hunt for the family and the Scout feels as though he has reached the end. NO NO… he has just begun. Now it’s time to give back and be a leader. But with the emphasis on advancement, the Scout and his family see no other needs that the unit can provide.
Some Troops believe that the Patrol Method is all you need. While I agree that the Patrol method is everything to the Patrol and health of the Troop, it is certainly not all you need. Where do you practice the Patrol method? At Troop meetings? Sure, some, but its the Outdoor program that makes the Patrol method come alive.. so no the Patrol method is not all you need. How do you put into practice the Ideals of Scouts, you know those ideals and values found in the Scout Oath and Law? You need a well planned and executed Service program in the life of the Troop. Service opportunities that engage the Scout and teach him to be a selfless servant to others. This is a wonderful leadership trait as well. Being a servant leader will certainly get the young man farther and reinforce the ideals of Scouting.
I once heard a quote, and I want to say it came from Baden Powell, “Show me a poorly uniformed troop and I’ll show you a poorly uniformed leader.” The uniform is an important part of Scouting. I have talked about this before so I won’t beat that horse to death, but the uniform is an essential part of Scouting. It builds the team. It helps with discipline. It is a great equalizer. The uniform connects us in the World Brotherhood of Scouting and is the most visible part of the Scout in public. It should be worn completely and correctly. Many adult leaders make a choice to allow jeans and other parts of the uniform to be exchanged. They claim that it is a money issue. It isn’t. A Scout is thrifty. He can always go mow a lawn, rake some leaves, or even sell popcorn to buy a new uniform or pants for it. Taking the easy way out on the uniform reflects the attitude of the leader to not use the methods of Scouting completely. “Attitude reflects leadership” so says my favorite quote from the movie Remember the Titans. This attitude of pick and choose can do more harm than good in the long run and it has been my observation that it can ultimately lead to a unit dying.
And no.. it’s not about the uniform. It’s about the methods. Those tried and true methods that lead our youth to a better understanding of who they are and what they will become. It teaches Character, Citizenship, and Fitness. And that my friends is why do Scouting. We believe this works and that is proven daily, weekly, monthly in units all across our country. It is proven in the Eagle Scouts that go on to do great things in their lives and in the Scouts that go into the world and become Dads that raise wonderful people. Scouting works, but we need to keep it alive. Using the eight methods will keep it from dying.
The methods need to be visible in your annual plan, in your interactions with the Scout, and in your attitude. That will reflect great leadership.
Have a Great Scouting Day!
This post is not going to sit well with some folks, but be that as it may, it is a message that I feel is an important part of the Character, Citizenship, and Overall fitness of the Scouts that we are trying to develop.
As with most ideas or thoughts that bounce through my mind, I find that themes reoccur or present themselves to me. And so as I go through my daily life I look for those things that can both make me a better person and pass on to our young men.
First, I have been observing a “homeless guy” over the past few months. Now please understand I am not being insensitive to the plight of the homeless here. I am absolutely not passing judgement and understand that there many folks out there with needs. I am also not expressing an opinion or solution about mental health issues that plague our country.. so.. with the caveats out of the way…
I finally had the opportunity to talk with this young man. I bought him a Frosty from Wendy’s and asked if I could ask him some questions. He agreed. I asked him why he was homeless. A simple question and he gave me a simple answer. He said he gave up. He gave up on school, he gave up on his family, he gave up on trying. I didn’t ask why, but I really wanted to know. It would have been too obvious to ask if he liked the results, so I left it alone. I did however ask how long he planned on staying on his current course. He answered by saying that it wasn’t that bad.. people in general are generous. He had no plan or expectation of life getting better.
I asked him if I could ask two more questions.. he agreed. Number one, are drugs involved? And number two, are you going to try to get help? To the first question he answered yes. That is why he is in Portland. Easy to get and cheap. To the second, he said he would like to get help. He added that he had dreams and goals, but giving up was easier. I thanked him and went on my way.
Second, as you know I am a football fan, especially when it comes to watching my youngest sons football team play. He plays for the College of the Redwoods and is a real good Quarterback. The team though has much to be improved. They are up and down and all over the place searching for consistency. The only thing that is consistent about the team is their willingness to give up. They seem to play for themselves and give up on their team mates. Because it is a Junior College, the players are looking at moving to higher Division Schools to continue playing football and advance their education. They are playing selfish to gain better stats without an understanding that if the team does well, they will get their stats. Giving up on plays and letting team mates down when the going gets tough.
So why do I care? I do not think it is acceptable to ever give up. As a young soldier it was always expected that we never give up. Giving up left people’s life in the balance. When people give up they don’t just give up on themselves, but there is always an effect to other people. When parents give up, the kids suffer. When employees give up, the work group suffers, when members of a Patrol give up, the whole Patrol is effected in a negative way. They end up moving in the wrong direction in the stages of team development or stay in a storming mode too long.
Giving up is a choice. It is a condition that while there are certainly circumstances that lend themselves to someone wanting to give up, there is never a reason to follow through.
Jerry, you are too insensitive.. no, I am a tired of seeing the effects of people who just give up. People get hurt when you give up. It’s not fair when people give up. As we talk about leadership with our Scouts we always start with the concept of being a servant leader or leading selflessly. If you can’t do that, you can’t lead. We also remind them that if they can not lead themselves they can not lead others. Having said that, giving up is in my opinion on of the most selfish things one can do.
So why do people give up? I don’t know. I don’t like it and I don’t allow it in my Troop. Scouts in my Troop are not allowed to say “I can’t”. If you believe that you can’t.. you are right. But that is not an option in life and the more we allow young men to give up, it becomes easier and easier to do. Scouts can do amazing things, but they need to have the self-confidence to push themselves. We need to give them permission to do so. When we accept the Scout saying “I can’t”.. we tell them it’s ok to pass or give up. Simply put.. it’s not ok.
So, no I don’t have the answer, but you can rest assured that I am fighting it by using my influence as a Scoutmaster to teach, coach, and mentor our Scouts to never, ever give up. I do not give up, so I expect them to take that attitude and grow into great men.
Can you imagine in our founding fathers gave up? Imagine if they decided it was not in their best interest or it was too hard. What if they did not test the resolve of their fellow countrymen to join the fight. We need not go to those extremes, but the principle is the same. Never give up on yourself or those around you.
Just something to think about.. I know I do.
A note on this post. It has taken me two weeks to put this together. It is a subject that has really been weighing on my heart and mind. I have talked to the Scouts of my Troop about this.. an ongoing discussion we have held over the past couple years. I finally wrapped it up tonight because once again, I talked with the homeless kid today. Still giving up. I don’t judge and make him out to be a bad guy. I see potential that is wasted. I see a young man who never was taught that giving up has long-term and far-reaching effects. He is living it. It saddens me.
Teach our Scouts the right way to become men.
The picture I used in this post is of me and a young man in my Troop. At the time, he was in his first year as a Boy Scout. What you don’t see in the picture are the big tears and the knocking knees this youngster had. What you also don’t see is him at the bottom of the rappel with a huge smile on his face knowing that he conquered fear and accomplished his goal of earning the climbing merit badge. You don’t see me 5 minutes after the picture was taken going over the edge with him and coaching him to stay with it and never give up. I am proud of that Scout and many others like him that make a choice not to quit.
Have a Great Scouting Day!
Watching an old episode of Bonanza the other day and as with most of the stories, the guys with the white hats typically come out on top while the bad guys in their black hats seem to have the opportunity to listen to Mr. Cartwright give them a lesson in good livin’.
The lesson this time was about finding your way in life. I don’t remember the particulars of the story, but Old Ben Cartwright shared some wisdom that I immediately felt a need to share. He said “It’s alright to find your way in life, it’s a lot easier if you have a map.” I could not help but think that this is a message that we often share with our Scouts. The map, our Oath and Law. There are many other maps out there also, The 10 Commandments, our laws, the Golden Rule. All pretty much lead you in the same direction and certainly make your life a little easier and worth living.
Baden Powell left us a good road map to a successful life in that first Scout Handbook. He shared with us the Values of Scouting, a good Oath to live by, and skills that help make a young boy a man.
It is important to find a good map to live well. Whether that is through your faith, our laws, or in our Scout Oath and Law it is of value to you and others to live right. I always go back to what BP said about Happiness in that true happiness comes from making others happy. It takes a good map for good living to do this. I think that there are many ways just as there are many maps to do this. I grew up in the Church and it gave me a firm foundation of how to treat other people. As the Golden rule says in essence to treat others as you want to be treated. I thought as a grew up that this was a Christian thing, but as I got older I learned and came to realize that happiness is universal and so too is the Golden Rule. This ethic of one good turn deserving another goes a long way in the happiness of the world. The Golden Rule often called The Ethic of Reciprocity is found in 21 of the Worlds Religions. Knowing that it is a wonder why we fight and how Religions the world over have caused so much pain in the world.
The Roman Pagan Religions taught “The law imprinted on the hearts of all men is to love the members of society as themselves.” Native America teaching lead us in “Do not wrong or hate your neighbor. For it is not he who you wrong, but yourself.” And hundreds of years before Christ walked our planet, “What is hateful to you, do not to your fellow-man. This is the law: all the rest is commentary.” from the Jewish faith.
I think that this last quote speaks more to me in the world that we live in today as it relates to the Golden Rule and Happiness.
So what does all of this have to do with our map? It’s simple. The map does not have to be complicated. It does not have to come with a degree in Social Science. The map needs to be clear and easy to understand. The map needs to have clear markings that lead us in the direction that we wish to go.
Our map in Scouting is the Scout Law. It is simple, clear, and leads us in the right direction. 12 simple words that are the foundation of our happiness and the happiness of others.
So you can have the Bible, The Tora, The Koran, or any other of the sacred text, what matters in the end is that you use them to do find good and happiness… more importantly, you use them to give happiness to others.
If you don’t you are not using them right. The same is the Oath and Law in Scouting. Words are great, Actions are better. Finding your way in life is a good venture… having a map certainly does make it easier.
Find and use your map.
Have a Great Scouting Day!
Ok.. you have had a few days to look over and answer your 20 Questions. I honestly hope that you took some time to answer the questions for yourself. It is said that the average New Years resolution lasts 9 days. Then we as a society just give up. It comes back to understanding that we in fact want to do something, change something, be something, but we don’t have a good map to get there. The reason that we lose the trail is that we don’t know what it looks like. We have no idea what the final product looks like. We do not have a picture of the desired outcome or how to get there.
Once you understand what your vision is, you can set a course to get there.
Now in all honesty the book has been written on this subject and I really have nothing new to add, just my understanding and perhaps my twist on the subject.
I have gone to many training sessions, courses and seminars on the goal setting, vision and leadership. In each course, the message is the same, the delivery is a bit different, but essentially it comes down to this when we are talking Vision.
“If you can see it.. you can be it”. The first time I heard this was at a training session about communicating Vision. The instructor quoted Zig Ziglar saying “If you can dream it, you can achieve it”. And that is what it comes down to. Dream it and go get it. So many times we do not allow ourselves to make our dreams come true because we fail to see our way to them. We all dream of the big house, the nice car, or the perfect Scout Troop. We do not see those things to reality because we miss out of following up with our Vision, or seeing our vision through to getting what we want.
So what is your Vision?
Your vision is simply that which you can see or imagine. It is what you anticipate happening or where you want to be.
Your vision is the most important part in goal setting, achieving your dream. You vision is not something that will come to you over night, that is why I think it important to reflect on those 20 questions. They are a starting point in discovering who you are and what you want out of life.
Within those 20 questions you will find your values and ideals. Those of us in Scouting have a solid base in that we agree on a set of values and ideals which are found in the Scout Oath and Law.
This is a great starting point for us to begin exploring our vision and setting that course.
It is important to create that starting point. Who are your friends and why do you like them? A simple question, but important in that it tells you a great deal about who you are. Who are your hero’s and why? Superman can leap tall buildings in single bound but my Dad taught me the value of Character. Take the questions serious and truly reflect on them with the understanding that the more solid your foundation the more relevant your vision will be.
See it and then set the course to be it.
Once you understand the values you live and why, you can generate or strengthen your resolve in getting the life you want.
Remember that this is YOUR Vision.. no one else’s. You may share elements of your vision, let’s say that you and your spouse share a dream. That’s fine. Share it and add it to your road map to getting what you want. It is important that spouses share their dreams. This gets you walking in the same direction toward your life’s goals. This will also force good communication and we all know that the better we communicate, the better our relationships.
Do not allow others to dictate YOUR vision. It belongs to you. It is YOUR dream, YOUR wants and desires. There are many parts of our lives in which we try to please someone else or live up to their expectations. Your vision sets an expectation of success for you.
Write it down. Once you can clearly see what you want.. Paint a picture of it. Use words to describe your vision. Basically write down what you want out of life. Once it’s on paper.. you will have your destination. Now lets map out way to get there. That will be the setting of your goals. Those bite size chunks, those little steps along the way to seeing your vision to reality.
We will talk about goal setting in a later post… give you something to look forward to.
This is a process that is worth sharing with your Scouts. The sooner they get in the habit of seeing their life in a way other than a set of rules and following the wants of teachers, parents, and yep.. Scout leaders.. they will achieve bigger and better things with their lives.
The Eagle project is a great tool in practicing setting a vision, goals, and accomplishing something great.
Le me know what you think.
Have a Great Scouting Day!
Guilty as charged. The company we keep, tan shirts, dedicated to being good Citizens, men of Character, and Fit.
I have heard this saying all my life. You are judged, as unpopular an opinion as that is these days, by the company that we keep. If you hang out with knuckle heads, you are viewed as a knuckle head. If you hang out with good people, you are judged as one of the good guys. This holds true in every case. I can not think of one example where people who hang out with bad people are viewed as one of the good ones.. or the better of the bad. Huh.. yeah.. I heard that one last week. “He’s a good guy, just hangs out with the wrong crowd.. he’s the better of the bad guys”.. but you know, he’s still among the bad guys. And yes, lets call it like it is. If they are bad, they are bad.
Too many times these day’s we try to give the benefit of the doubt or try to find that silver lining. Sometimes it’s just not there. More times than not there are opportunities for behavior change and it is neglected. I don’t buy the idea that circumstances create a lack of opportunity. It’s there, it just needs to be taken. I have known many people who came from bad circumstances only to find opportunity, take it, and make something good of their lives.
Here is the deal. We have Scouting. Scouting is available everywhere. Now, it certain circles it may not seem “cool”..so explore the alternative. Join our Scouting gang, or join a thug gang. In both circumstances you will find support, belonging, and a set of values. The difference is one leads to good, the other doesn’t. It comes down to choices.
Parents have a lot to do with this. As a young man growing they assist in creating the environment that will lead their son to hanging with the right crowd. Generations of “good guys” typically lead to more good guys. On the other hand the lack of want to.. the fact that the path of least resistance creates the easy road down a path which lacks character puts young men in the bad category.
I don’t mind calling like it is. The people who I associate with are good. I need not worry about their character. I don’t have to worry about the values that they live. I don’t have to worry about the impression that I leave with the friends I keep.
I see our young men.. they look for that easy road. That road will never lead the right way. As a Scoutmaster, it is my job to help the parents in creating that environment which leads to good character and values. Being a role model in that endeavor is part of the program.
Too often we forget as Scouters that we have an obligation to create those conditions for the Scout. We get wrapped up in making Eagle Scouts that we forget what we are really there for. Citizens of Character.
Now Eagle Scouts that hang out with Eagle Scouts is a good group to be associated with.. You will certainly be judged by that standard.
I tell ever Scout of our Troop that attains the rank of Eagle that up till now they had completed and earned the rank of Eagle Scout, from that day forward they must prove that they are worthy of being one.
That is the company that they keep. It is the company we keep. We are judged in that company. I am happy with that.
Have a Great Scouting Day!
During Scoutmaster conferences I often ask the Scout what the Scout Oath and Law mean to them. In their own words what do the values and the promises found in the Oath and Law mean.
It seems that, by and large, there is a lack of knowledge in so far as defining what “Duty” means with our younger Scouts. With our older Scouts too for that matter.
When I was a young Scout, right after we walked up hill both ways in the snow, it seems to me that we were taught in School, home, and Church what Duty meant and what our role was in keeping our promises and understanding what our duty was when it comes to our daily lives. In Scouts we knew what our duty was when it came to being Reverent and Helpful. We had an understanding about our Duty to our Country.
The other night I took the opportunity while talking with a young man during a Scoutmaster Conference to discuss what duty meant and what he needed to know about it. The discussion started because the Scout didn’t understand why he said those words when he recited the Scout Oath.
I started with a basic definition so he could get at least an understanding of duty. I first asked if he felt like he had a responsibility to be helpful. He said yes. I asked if he felt an obligation to be a good citizen. He said yes, but really didn’t know what that really meant at his age. I then asked him if he felt that he should be committed to doing his best, staying healthy, and doing well in school so he could have a better life. All of those he felt that he was committed to.
I told him that duty is just that, a responsibility, a commitment, and an obligation to something. In our case as Scouts those are found in our Scout Oath to God and our Country, to other people, and to ourselves.
Duty to me has always been a solid concept of how we live our lives. As a soldier, I was bound to serving our Country and as a leader my duty was to the soldiers I led.
As a Father, my responsibility has always been to making me children good people. I was told once that it is not my job as a Dad to raise good children, rather it was my duty to raise good adults.
As a Husband my obligation is to my wife. To be her partner through thick and thin and to show her unconditional love.
As a Scout leader I am committed to men of Character. Making Eagle Scouts is not my priority, teaching young men to grow up and be men that have Character, are good citizens, and have an understanding and habit of being fit. That is what is important to me. Why? Because it is my Duty.
I shared these things to my young Scout. It helped him gain a better understanding of why, in the Scout Oath, we use the term “Duty”.
Knowing that it make the Scout Law more important, it focuses the Scouts outlook toward God and Country and helping others. It creates a want to be his best and take care of himself and those around him.
Some may say that I am reading into this, I say no… I am teaching it for what it is. A promise.
If we don’t keep our promises we compromise our character, when we do that, we have nothing. We need to understand that we have a Duty to be good Scouts, Scouts that live the Oath and Law in our daily lives.
It is the foundation of Scouting. Baden Powell understood that when he started this. These concepts have been passed from generation to generation. William “Green Bar Bill” Hillcourt understood this and made it the hallmark of his writings on Scouting. Scoutmasters for years have held true to these concepts in the teaching their Scouts and for whatever reason there has been a disconnect in our young men today. It is my duty to change that. I will do that one Scout at a time.
Do you feel that same obligation?
Have a Great Scouting Day!
You can always tell when we have officially run out of real problems. We make some.
In a recent discussion with a group of Scouters the issue of knives came up. What is the “Official Policy” on what a Scout can and can not carry. What is the length that he can or can not have?
OK.. so I will give you the “Officially Policy” and then some opinion.
Page 60 of the Guide to Safe Scouting states; “A sharp pocketknife with a can opener on it is an invaluable backcountry tool. Keep it clean, sharp, and handy. Avoid large sheath knives. They are heavy and awkward to carry, and unnecessary for most camp chores except for cleaning fish. Since its inception, Boy Scouting has relied heavily on an outdoor program to achieve its objectives. This program meets more of the purposes of Scouting than any other single feature. We believe we have a duty to instill in our members, youth and adult, the knowledge of how to use, handle, and store legally owned knives with the highest concern for safety and responsibility.Remember—knives are not allowed on school premises, nor can they be taken aboard commercial aircraft.”
Further, from the Boy Scouts of America website “Sheath knives are not prohibited by the BSA, but they may be regulated by state or local ordinances and/or by camp “rules.” We recommend that the right tool for the job be used (cutting branches or ropes). We do not encourage wearing them at the waist as injury could occur during falls.” reference General Health and Safety FAQ’s
The BSA does not restrict the length of the blade, nor does it require a blade to be folding or fixed. The policy requires that we abide by state and local rules and that we use the right tool for the right job.
The question came up as to what I allow the Scouts in my Troop to wear/use. Here is how I see it.
The Scout is required to earn his Totin’ Chip before he is allowed to carry and use a Knife, Saw, and Ax. The Totin’ Chip certifies that the Scout has the right to carry and use woods tools. The Scout must show his Scout leader that he understands his responsibility to do the following:
Read and understand woods tools use and safety rules from the Boy Scout Handbook.
Demonstrate proper handling, care, and use of the pocket knife, ax, and saw.
Use knife, ax, and saw as tools, not playthings.
Respect all safety rules to protect others.
Respect property. Cut living and dead trees only with permission and good reason.
Subscribe to the Outdoor Code.
Once the Scout has demonstrated that he can use the knife safely and he agrees to use it as a tool then the Scout can be held in account. He can lose the privilege of carrying a knife as quick as he earn the right to use it.
If a Scout would like to carry a sheath knife, I have no problem with it. I recommend that he chooses one that is the right tool for what he is using it for. I recommend that the blade be no more than 4 inches. This way he has good control over it and it complies with local rules. Since I live in Oregon, it is important for me to know what the laws are. According the Boy Scouts of America, it is the local laws and policies that dictate what a Scout can and can not carry.
In Oregon, it is legal to own pretty much any knife and you can carry it (open carry) anytime you want. Certain exceptions apply of course, but for our purpose a Scout can carry pretty much any knife he wants.
Now, having said that, it comes down to the right tool for the job.
So the discussion then becomes, what does a Scout use his knife for?
Cutting kindling for fires, cutting line or rope, preparing meals, and whittling for the most part. So what is the right tool for those jobs. Certainly a sword would not be appropriate and a Rambo survival knife is not necessary either. A simple pocket or sheath knife will do.
This is where the adult leader steps in to be a teacher. It is not a matter of what they can carry, it becomes a matter of what do you use it for? In that discussion with your Scouts you outline the right tool for the job and allow them to make that reasonable choice. I will tell you with 100% certainty that we have had that talk and have never seen a “Rambo Knife” on a camp out.
I personally carry a Mora knife. It is sharp, handy, and useful. The particular model I carry is made by Mora and Light My Fire. It has a striker in the handle. It has a 3 1/2 blade and I have used it to butter bread and baton wood for a camp fire. It has a hard sheath which locks the knife in place. Here is a little video from Light my Fire on the knife that I carry.
We recommend that our Scouts only carry a small knife. A pocket knife or a sheath knife either one is ok. We ask that they focus on the job and using the right tool. Many of our Scouts carry a multi tool like the Leatherman. This is fine also. The fact of the matter is that I just want them to use it properly… or get your right taken away.
That is the rule that we should focus on, not the knife itself.
Like I said, I think we have far too much time on our hands and not enough real problems that we are worried about the length of a blade. As with most if not all things in Scouting you must train them and then trust them.
Do you have a unit policy when it comes to knives? I am curious to hear what that looks like.
Have a Great Scouting Day!
Here is the Scoutmaster Minute that I gave to our Troop the other night… Hope you find it useful.
As you travel on the trail to First Class Scout you find that there are many skills that you develop. You learn them and eventually master them well enough to use them in your daily lives, while on camp outs and even teach them to other people.
Learning to use the Map and Compass is one such skill that takes practice and hands on use. Once you master the use of the Map and Compass you will always know the direction you heading and will be able to find your way.
The Map shows you the terrain. It lets you know where you are and where you are going. It’s colors represent what is on the ground around you and the obstacles that you will face. As you read the map, you see the hills and valleys that you will be trekking on. It shows you where you can find water and other resources. The map can tell you where the trail is easy or hard or give you options for a detour. Using you map, you always know where you are and a clear path to where you want to go.
The Compass is the other tool that when used with your map gives you clear direction. Knowing how to use the compass properly will allow you to set your course in the right direction. It orients your map and gives you an accurate picture of what is ahead. Without the compass, the map is just a picture of the section of earth you are traveling on. Add the compass and you have accurate and steady direction. The compass is always true. It can set you on the path that will get you to your destination.
These two tools are important in your life. Yes, we have GPS now and that is very helpful, but the GPS will never replace a good map and compass.
We have another map and compass that get us headed in the right direction and keep us on track to our destination. The Scout Oath and Law.
The Oath is our map. It gives us a clear picture of the person that we should be. It has features much like the map. Duty, Honor, and being Selfless are some of the marks we see in Oath. If we use it, we will know the landscape of our lives and will be able to stay the course.
The Scout Law is our compass. It is the steady set of values, unchanging, that when used with the Scout Oath will be our guide on the trail of life.
The Law points you in the direction of our values that make you the person that you are. Like the compass it has a steadfast needle that ensures your heading is true.
Using the Oath and Law together, like the map and compass these tools will set your course to being a man of Character, a good Citizen, and promote in yourself and other fitness in your mind, body, and heart.
As we have traveled that trail to First Class, weather is is recent or in the past, or if you are just starting that journey, remember that the skills you develop today are there for you to use for the rest of your life. Focus on these skills they will make a difference not only on a camp out but every day that you wake up and look in the mirror starting your Great Scouting Day!
Set your azimuth to achieve your goals and keep checking your map to stay on course.
Have a Great Scouting Day!